Hi @maxcady ,
This is a classical problem you have here: uneven Scale:

With the Handle in Object Mode, CTRL+A > Apply > Scale.
The side of the Handle is also very wobbly, if that is intentional, than that’s fine, otherwise, select the side and then S, Y, 0 to flatten it.
You might also want to switch the Pivot Point back to Median Point (is on Individual Origins at the moment).