@yukinoh1989 Okay, I’m by no means skilled when it comes to lighting, and I imagine there’s a much more intelligent, robust way to do this.
HOWEVER
Doing things intelligently isn’t my style, so this is what I got tinkering around, and it’s rather simple.
All you need to do is get a cube and essentially squeeze it between the two lights so it separates them but don’t make it too big so it doesn’t clip through the pumpkin.

You should then end up with something like this:

It’s not perfect by any means but I’m sure you can tweak around with it to get what you want. Hope this pushes you in the right direction!