@williamatics The more I look at your pear the more I think: “That’s a really good pear.” The texture is spot on! As for matching the source image, I think yours really needs a similar defocused background. The black background is an immediate disconnect. It would likely also provide a good reflection source for subtle fresnel reflectivity. Overall it’s a pretty simple light match too..as in it looks like one or two lights, no background. I give it a C+
Sorry to hear about the Eevee material weirdness. Did you figure it out? It looks to me like it could be the auto texture space funk that I ran into in last week’s stream.