Reply To: BC4-1810 Homework, mahir07

Forum Archive BC4-1810 Homework, mahir07 Reply To: BC4-1810 Homework, mahir07

#42634
Kent Trammell
Participant

    @mahir07 You should be happy with your arch viz result! It’s quite nice. On a scale from 1-10, 1 being unrealistic and 10 be photo-real, I’d give it a 8. Which is a compliment – 9’s are rare and 10’s are super rare.

    I have 2 criticisms. One is the texture in the window which I talked about in depth during yesterday’s stream (recording is being exported as I type, will be available soon). Basically it makes the room feel like it’s as high as the top of the city’s tallest building. While that’s not impossible, it’s a distraction from the main purpose of the render: the room itself. It also calls into question the perspective of the room vs the perspective of the outside city.

    Also the room feels uniformly bright. Since there’s apparently only one window in the room and no interior lights turned on, I would expect the light to be a clear gradient from the window side of the room and gradually diminishing toward the camera.

    Overall though it’s a solid arch viz rende. Materials are good, I like the subtle reflections in the floor, models are great. An A in my book.

    Your light match also looks quite good. I love the source you picked. The biggest difference I see is that the backlight/rim light is visible in the source’s yellow puddle reflection but it isn’t in yours. Overall that’s a small note though. B+ from me.