@silentheart00 Thank your criticism! I’ll certainly look into those before modeling my next sword.
Here’s the sword in the OpenGL renders: https://skfb.ly/6CNwz I added some loops to the pommel as it had only a few of them and looked very blocky, I also removed the supporting edges but topology is pretty much the same.
I like the first sword too (I actually like all of them :D) but it was the last one I drew so I rushed it a bit.

I changed the hilt with the third one. There are two strips of leather wrapped around the hilt, I might change the color of the tan one. Those two hook looking shapes extrude from the guard and go through the ring so shading them was a bit difficult and the result isn’t that great.