The mystery of Rigify

perhaps @danpro  can help with this? he tends to understand about bone heat weight and such things…

Bone Heat Failed To Find Solution errors can happen with any armature. It’s not caused by or exclusive to Rigify. The error is caused most often by errors in the mesh.

A few reasons for the error:

1. Overlapping geometry. The bone heat algorithm cannot “see” the mesh behind the folded geometry and throws the error.

 Fix: Check the mesh for errors. Remove Doubles. Fix intersecting geometry. Or assign weights manually.

2. Flipped normals. Bone heat works from the inside out. If the faces of the mesh are not facing outward, they are blocking the bone heat.

 Fix: Recalculate Normals. Or assign weights manually.

3. Unapplied scale on the mesh (scale is not 1,1,1) or differences in scale between the mesh and the armature can cause weighting issues. 

 Fix: Apply the transforms of the mesh before parenting to the armature. Ideally. the mesh and the armature  should have the same origin and the origin should be at the world center.

One method to find the problem area is to separate the mesh by loose parts. (Select the mesh in Edit Mode, Select all vertices (Hotkey A),  Hotkey P, Loose parts.) After the mesh has been separated, try parenting each mesh to the armature with Automatic Weights. If all parts successfully auto weight correctly, rejoin the separate meshes into a single mesh again.

I hope that helps.

Good luck!

I assume that what you are showing above is your metarig and in that case I’m not surprised.

The thing to understand about rigify is that you have to follow the recipe. adding an extra set of arms is ok, but adding additional joints to limbs is going to confuse the algorithm that expects the two boned arm.

I just tried to see if deleting both the chest and pelvis bones would result in your error and No. it appears you dont need those bones to generate a rig.

The major problem you added to  or subdivided the superlimbs which would scare the compiler, I mean the human form does not have three elbows. If you want bendy arms just change the type to tentacle in pose mode . Or youknow just use the normal arms and abuse the hell out to the tweak bones to get the rubberhose arm effect.

Ah, never mind, I figured it out. I was trying to separate loose parts by selecting the mesh in vertex mode, but of course, it needs to be in face mode! So I did that, and now it works. Wanted to put this here in case anyone else overlooks this. 

hfs this worked. its so dumb, but makes sense at the same time.

i had spent 3 days fixing up a pretty high poly model and it parented fine. that was couple weeks back. 

but removed parenting cuz it messed up all the hair particles.

then i rescaled it later ( which i totally forgot about ). and now when i tried to parent the same mesh with same armature the “heat weighting failed” showd up again. can’t put my frustration into words.

u r a lifesaver bruv. thnx a lot.