It’s funny I was in the process of doing the exact same thing! (but on a lesser scale). I looked through my instagram and pinterest and assembled images of art that I loved, that most closely resembled my strengths and goals in one way or another. I didn’t go into all the graphing you did, or assembling and analyzing all of my work, but I think that might be my next step.
It feels like your Battered Bunny and Pokemon piece are closest to what your goals are. In such that they display a more dramatic/contrasted lighting and the Pokemon piece has more texture. It seems like your example images all have a larger display of texture and texture variety. And I agree with Mark Fricker in that the goal pieces also appear darker in mood and subject than your own example. It’s really clear zlready how big of a jump you’ve taken with you’re new piece! I dig it.
If I posted here, or in my sketchbook thread, would you be willing to take a look and see what jumps out at you from my own “collection of goals” as being consistent between them? Another viewpoint is always helpful